The Dangerous Business of Goring Someone Else’s Ox – Mainstream Media Getting the Manosphere Wrong Over and Over Again (The Aurelius File, 11)

The lair of the tiger. The tiger jumped and jumped at the throat of his enemy, vintage engraved illustration. Journal des Voyage, Travel Journal, (1880-81).
Licensed from Shutterstock.

Let’s begin with an axiomatic truth: Republic, like Empire, can tolerate a limited left-wing identity politics, but Republic, like Empire, cannot endure a right-wing identity politics. Like the element iron to a burning sun – right-wing identity politics will dissolve and devour the tenuous strands of unity that cohere post-tribal Republic. History has been incomparably painful in teaching this lesson and everyone – instinctively – knows this. Modern Europe, where it is said in Germany that “the only thing to the right of the Christian Democrats is the wall”, is built from the ground up on the truth of this … Continue reading

After November 2014 – a Future for the Blue Dogs? – Part I

Licensed from Shutterstock - Narcissus Nicaise perilous adventures in the Congo. He had before him a fearsome sea monster, vintage engraved illustration. Journal des Voyage, Travel Journal, (1880-81).

Despite my headline (ehhhh, Blue … dog … talking) I’d almost didn’t notice.  For one thing – my candidate won. But it has managed to intrude on my awareness that November, 2014 did not go well for the dwindling political collective I’ve placed so much hope in, the Blue Dogs.  The Blue Dog beating is unpacked fairly well and succinctly and, I would add, with some relish – for us at Daily Kos here.  If the gravity of it isn’t immediately familiar to you I recommend taking a look the article as it is short and the reader quickly gets … Continue reading

Dear Conservatives – to Fight the Cultural Wars – forget Ayn Rand and Teach English Common Law

The Magna Carta (licensed from Shutterstock)

Thesis: current conservative approaches to fighting the culture wars inevitably result in setback or failure.  You cannot cure people who have drunk the Orwellian Koolaid of left-wing Identity Politics – but you can inoculate people against it in the first place – by teaching English Common Law.  Teach it long, teach it early, teach it middle and teach it late – teach it to everyone, volunteer to teach it yourself, pass laws to require that it be taught – and teach it with the most feverish intensity to those who are most likely to fall prey to the Orwellian Koolaid. … Continue reading

The Blue Dog Democrats and Defining 21st Century Liberalism during a Crisis of Identity – Two Organizing Principles

Old engraved portrait of George Potter, British trade unionist. By unknown author, published on L'Illustration, Journal Universel, Paris, 1868.  Licensed from Shutterstock.

Liberalism – distinct as such from both conservatism and Marxism – clings to life in 21st century American political experience in the form of the Blue Dog caucus.  But what is liberalism?  Here I propose two organizing principles: Socially – liberalism is based on an ethical system of Kantian autonomy. Economically – liberalism is based on common market capitalism – the old Scottish sense of capitalism going back to Adam Smith himself which sought equity in the market for people, rather than capital as an end unto itself. Suffice to say from the get-go that when we speak of identity … Continue reading

Blue Dog Democrat Economics – In Super Basic Form

Free trade is not a free market Common Markets are the remedy for the problem of free trade We want public market capitalism, not socialism or free market capitalism The corporate tax does not make any sense, abolish it Replace the corporate tax with corporate law reform that follows the successful German model Property belongs to the person, the market belongs to the people Simplify the tax code – use the Presidential veto, because that’s the only thing that will work In slightly more words: Free Trade is Not a Free Market Free trade is not a free market.  Free … Continue reading

Eight Principles of Blue Dog Democrat Economics – Towards the Fair Market Economy of the Future

Outside Washington Market, New York

In On Liberty, John Stuart Mill put this insurpassable observation to words: “He who knows only his own side of the case knows little of that. ” And it so happens that in places where I am wont to discuss such matters with Republicans and other conservatives, one of my favored observations to note is that the most likely difference between a Democrat who is a capitalist and a Republican who is the same is this: Where the Republican likely gives evidence of the stultifying influences of Ayn Rand The Democrat has actually read Adam Smith (and David Riccardo, and Karl … Continue reading

The Ghost of Karl Marx Lectures on Your Imminent Replacement with a Robot

Licensed from Shutterstock - Portrait of Karl Marx on an East German banknote - money no more in use since the reunification of germany in 1991.

Bluedog is not a Marxist. But then again Bluedog isn’t a libertarian either and though I am not a libertarian, well: I think you should read and understand your John Locke.  I think that’s very important.  Actually: both John Locke and Adam Smith – oh, and while your at it, read up on David Riccardo and Milton Friedman and Friedrich von Hayek.  Read them all, it’ll be good for you – especially if you have the misfortune of having read Ayn Rand without first having read her betters. But – not today.  Today let’s talk about Karl Marx. Because you see … Continue reading

The Aurelius File (10) – Erdogan, Kobani, ISIS and the Turkish Point of View

Licensed from Shutterstock - Ottoman Empire (Turkey) coat of arms / vintage illustration from Meyers Konversations-Lexik on 1897

One need not agree with Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan’s position not to intervene to reverse the advance of ISIS in the Syrian city of Kobani – but one should still be able to place himself in Erdogan’s shoes and understand it so I don’t know why people are so puzzled or think that Turkey is especially vile for demurring from this opportunity to enter conflict. Erdogan is a head of state.  As head of state of the nation of Turkey he doesn’t just have a job – he has imperatives.  Among his imperatives are the best interests of the people … Continue reading

Illustrators and Photographers Take Note: I won’t be using iStockPhoto Anymore

So let’s get this part out of the way – if you are a creator – I’m the guy you like, namely because: I pay to use your creations But I’m not a chump, which brings us to the matter of iStockPhoto. Explore BluedogTalking and you will find many images in use – probably 95% come from iStockPhoto with the remaining 5% being images I created or images I directly requested permission to use from their owners. Until recently iStockPhoto had a scheme for licensing use that I considered fair.  I could buy “credits” in bulk which usually amounted to … Continue reading

The Aurelius File (9) – Understanding ISIS: It’s the Nihilism, Stupid

The Equestrian Statue of Marcus Aurelius in Rome, Italy

To put it simply, “It’s the nihilism stupid”. In the National Review Jonah Goldberg describes it as a “foreign legion for losers“.  At The New Republic Graeme Wood explores three personality profiles of individuals who went on to join ISIS. Both get elements of the truth, but to really put a simple finger on it – one that cracks open the black box and exposes in plain light the ugly little critter hiding inside – our word is “nihilism”. Observing ISIS I have not been satisfied by any of the routine standard answers thrown at such groups. The predictable appellations … Continue reading

The Difference a Father Makes – Issue 9 – Pizza Homework

Pond In The City
1893 Engraving

“In a paper published last year, Autor, working in collaboration with a fellow M.I.T. economist, Melanie Wasserman, found that ‘the labor market trajectory of males in the U.S. has turned downward along four dimensions: skills acquisition; employment rates; occupational stature; and real wage levels.’ The trends have been much worse for men than women because ‘the absence of stable fathers from children’s lives has particularly significant adverse consequences for boys’ psychosocial development and educational achievement.’ “Autor and Wasserman cite data showing that ‘after controlling for a host of individual and family characteristics, growing up in a single-parent home appears to significantly decrease the probability … Continue reading

The Aurelius File (6) – Defeating ISIS – Not Such a Mystery

Vintage engraving from 1876 from of the Battle of Dreux. The Battle of Dreux was fought on 19 December 1562 between Catholics and Huguenots.

“Prohibit the taking of omens, and do away with superstitious doubts. Then, until death itself comes, no calamity need be feared.” Sun Tzu President Obama says he has no strategy on ISIS.  Conservatives are all over him for it.  Much hand-wringing is spent.  We – the most powerful nation on earth – we – Empire in the 21st Century – act as if we are intimidated by a band of nihilist thugs.  We – go on as if succumbing to psychological warfare. We – forget who, and what – we are. But everyone is not forgetting what they are, or … Continue reading

The Aurelius File (5) – Hindsight: Putin Does Want a Fight ( if not a War ) that He Can Win – Reverse Engineering the Thinking of Putin’s Supply Professionals

The Equestrian Statue of Marcus Aurelius in Rome, Italy

Summary: We cannot read Putin’s mind – but we can “reverse engineer” the apparent decisions of his supply professionals who are assuredly at work provisioning his Ukrainian war making adventure so as to see what they are thinking.  This effort can be profitable. An analysis of Russian behavior in Ukraine based on publicly available civilian news accounts sustains the conclusion that control of the terms of the theater of operation is essential to the Russian prosecution of a war effort. Putin has demonstrated little or no appetite for a direct frontal assault and is surely aware of the destabilizing effect of … Continue reading

The Aurelius File (8) – You Could be Forgiven if You Didn’t Realize We Routed ISIS Three Times in Six Days

iStock_000032865110_Small

ISIS is confused, fitful and demoralized.  But you wouldn’t know that if you were succumbing to the psychological warfare that our media and our military and civilian leadership show every sign of falling victim to. Let’s get straight to details. ISIS – Getting Routed 3 Times in 6 Days – a Retrospective Route #1: Sinjar – Reference (in the reference – see the section “U.S. Airstrikes and Humanitarian Aid”) After ISIS surprised the world by an initial defeat of Kurdish Peshmerga fighters near Sinjar on August 3, with US airstrikes to support Peshmerga on the ground the ISIS siege was broken … Continue reading

The Aurelius File (7) – You are the United States of America – Don’t Succumb to Psychological Warfare and Lose your Sh*t over ISIS!

The Equestrian Statue of Marcus Aurelius in Rome, Italy

 ”The best revenge is to be unlike him who performed the injury… “The best revenge is not to be like your enemy.” Marcus Aurelius   The original title of this piece was going to be “The United States – the One Nation with the Power of Empire – Succumbs to Psychological Warfare”. That’s a right message – but doesn’t speak quite loudly enough. Anyway – my what a long way we’ve come.  Here’s a short review of the quantum leap in collective psychological space we have jumped in seven months:     January, 2014 ISIS in World Affairs What Americans … Continue reading

The Difference a Father Makes – Issue 8 – Raising a PTSD Child (II) – Strategies for Managing Mood Cycles

Pond In The City
1893 Engraving

The first issue of this series, including front matter on what the series is about and what it is intended to address, is available here. * * * * * * * * * * In the last issue I talked about the basic task – as I experience it – of being a parent of a child with PTSD which is to manage moods and much of that entails simply understanding what moods are, how to recognize them, how to recognize changes in mood state and the fact of our non-helplessness, our ability to affect what these states are, their duration, … Continue reading

Blue Dog Economics – Free Markets, Free Trade and Right-Wing Economic and Cultural Sophistry

A group of Victorian children playing at being at school, with one boy acting as the teacher and the dog watching attentively. From “Early Days” for the year 1893, published by the Early Days Office, London

The following piece is adapted from a Disqus post I put at the National Review today in response to an article by Mark Krikorian, “Skilled Immigration: Not All Its Cracked Up to Be” (August 18, 2014 12:18 PM). The issue of free trade is a real sore spot for me as it relates to the right.  The right talks a good game on economics – it is as I’ve said in the About of this blog “Cock-sure and ignorant as hell.” The right-wing approach on free trade and immigration powerfully achieves two aims – one being more the intent, the other … Continue reading

The Aurelius File (4) – Defending the Kurds is Defending Ukraine and Preventing War with Russia

The Equestrian Statue of Marcus Aurelius in Rome, Italy

Note to reader: for updated analysis of events in Russia and Ukraine as of August 31st please see here. * * * * * * * * * There are three conditions under international law wherein it is legal for a nation to take military action: In self-defense – as when a nation is militarily attacked Under treaty and/or invitation – such as when a treaty bonds one nation to defend another such as NATO or the Treaty of Mutual Cooperation and Security between the United States and Japan, OR – such as in the case of Iraq where a sovereign power’s … Continue reading

The Difference a Father Makes – Issue 7 – Raising a PTSD Child (I)

Pond In The City
1893 Engraving

The first issue of this series, including front matter on what the series is about and what it is intended to address, is available here. * * * * * * * * * * I’ve mentioned in an earlier post that younger is diagnosed with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, PTSD – yes – the same thing corpsmen and women notoriously return from combat afflicted with. There’s a lot I’ve learned about PTSD and raising a child suffering from the condition that it seems worthwhile to share. I will titrate this out bit-by-bit – as I have no comprehensive catalog in my … Continue reading

The Difference a Father Makes – Issue 6 – Daddy Memory Tricks

Pond In The City
1893 Engraving

The first issue of this series, including front matter on what the series is about and what it is intended to address, is available here. * * * * * * * * * * The modern term is “math facts”.  Math facts are: having your kid run through drills to memorize multiplication tables for numbers 1 through 12.  We consider “drilling” to be a rude term and “multiplication tables” to be offensive to polite company when talking about education nowadays, so we changed the description to “math facts”, but it hasn’t changed the fact that whatever we call it, it … Continue reading

The Difference a Father Makes – Issue 5 – Another Small Victory

Pond In The City
1893 Engraving

The first issue of this series, including front matter on what the series is about and what it is intended to address, is available here. * * * * * * * * * * A good way to think about a child with PTSD is in terms of range. All children, as all adults, have range. Ideally we have within our range some place where we are genuinely pleasant people for others to be around, but we all lapse from time to time and for a variety of reasons, many of which are quite legitimate. So think of a kid. She’s … Continue reading

The Difference a Father Makes – Issue 4 – Two Small Victories

Pond In The City
1893 Engraving

The first issue of this series, including front matter on what the series is about and what it is intended to address, is available here. * * * * * * * * * * Saturday night was a birthday party at my sister’s house for the boys’ cousins.  My youngest, who I’ve mentioned in another post suffers from PTSD, also is a picky eater.  Now – the picky eating isn’t really the point in what I am about to make. I am not sure if it is the PTSD or something else – but one aspect of my younger is that … Continue reading

The Manosphere’s Basement Dwelling One Man Self Appointed Unaccountable Bad Credit Bad Thought Reporting Agency

Antique illustration of astrology

David Futrelle   This is part of the “house training” feature of my blog. And … by the way – he changed his site from its original “manboobz.com”, which I guess was backfiring on him, to “wehuntedthemammoth.com”. The former will still forward you to his site though and I don’t really see where we should let him off for past mistakes, being as he is in the business of making sure others – strangers to him as it were – are never, ever let off, for past mistakes. Oh yeah – and I’m sorry – I don’t really know if … Continue reading

The Aurelius File (3) – The Strategic Catastrophe of Moral Failure – Why We Must Defend the Kurds

The Equestrian Statue of Marcus Aurelius in Rome, Italy

Consider the following table:   Legal Right to Act Military Ability to Act Libya Yes (UN Security Council) Yes Syria No Unlikely Crimea No Unlikely Iraq/Kurdistan Yes (Invitation of the sovereign power in Baghdad) Yes The table above is so important because it gives us the succinct means with which to think about something important: It is one thing when the US wants to act to prevent genocide But either legally or militarily is unable to do so It is another thing entirely when… …the US is both legally and militarily capable of preventing genocide …and those at greatest risk … Continue reading

Stardusk Exnihilates a Chimera and Baby Meaning is Born: Of Men and Women, Meaning and Love

Look closely - do you see (r(θ) = A eθ cot α) in there (hint: Google "Spira Mirabilis)? If it's there and there's no conscious being to recognize it, what does it mean about what we see in these swirling mists? The more rudimentary [(x−h)2+(y−k)2=r2] can be seen pretty clearly in there too. You've heard the expression before that "if a tree falls in the forest and there is no one to hear it ...", but consider: the mathematical expression (r(θ) = A eθ cot α) is in these mists - it is there - and that expression, means something - so what do we make of the expression, or the mists - if they exist without someone to perceive them? ... On the other hand - and more importantly: if the expression is in there and there is a conscious being to recognize it (i.e.: you) ... then what does that tell suggest to you about what meaning is?

“There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older fish swimming the other way, who nods at them and says ‘Morning, boys. How’s the water?’ And the two young fish swim on for a bit, and then eventually one of them looks over at the other and goes ‘What the hell is water?’” David Foster Wallace “The book of love has music in it, in fact that’s where music comes from” From The Book of Love Originally performed by the Magnetic Fields My Favorite Post Title This is officially my favorite post title so … Continue reading

The Difference a Father Makes – Issue 3 – Better than the “Terror of Indecision”

Pond In The City
1893 Engraving

The first issue of this series, including front matter on what the series is about and what it is intended to address, is available here. * * * * * * * * * * “The risk of a wrong decision is preferable to the terror of indecision.” Moses Maimonides Yesterday (Wednesday) was the third day of my oldest coming home on the bus.  Monday and Tuesday I made sure I was home when he got there, this would be the first day I’d be away and he’d get home on his own.  Now begins the practice of creating in him the … Continue reading

The Difference a Father Makes – Issue 2 – The First Day of School

Pond In The City
1893 Engraving

The first issue of this series, including front matter on what the series is about and what it is intended to address, is available here. * * * * * * * * * * Today (actually Monday the 4th … this was published two days later as the smart phone I typed it on died before I could publish) was the first day of school. Wishing the event to be as low stress as possible I woke at 5:30 AM and showered and dressed myself for work so that would all be out of the way. I then cooked myself an … Continue reading

The Difference a Father Makes – 1st Issue – The Day Before the First Day of School

Pond In The City
1893 Engraving

About this series: ours is an era that needs to be convinced, over an over again, simply of the mere benefits (as if they might not exist), of an institution known since Mesopotamian times to be essential to human well-being, adult formation, the very possibility of childhood, and to the building blocks of civilization: Fatherhood Towards this end – we are engaging in study after study that, as if for the first time, “discovers” that fathers and fatherhood, matter. Who would have guessed? These, eh, “discoveries” – while true, and obvious in a pathetic yet needed way – tend to … Continue reading

For Conservatives and Liberals – Thinking about the Manosphere while Working a Democratic Party Phone Bank

This vintage engraving is an 18th century political cartoon, a parody of an election in 18th century England. In this scene, titled "Polling at the Hustings", the candidate arrives at a crowded polling station. It is the creation of William Hogarth (1697 - 1764).

To my knowledge no one has yet polled the manosphere to ascertain where the real concentrations of political ideology lie on it.  I’m not even sure how such a poll could be done.  What I do know is that taking in some four years of following the manosphere, including reading the tens of thousands of comments on popular blogs there, it’s hard not to miss that there are several varieties of conservatism finding expression. That said – I want to be clear about something – and this is for my liberal and mainstream readers: To call the manosphere any of … Continue reading

When Liberals Self Sooth – The New Republic talks Elite Higher Education and Misses Financialization and the Phenotypic Diversity of Poverty

iStock_000019520658Small

As a recent/former university educator I can’t say that I wasn’t interested in two articles published in The New Republic concerned with whether or not we parents should send our kids to Ivy League colleges.  The first, by William Deresiewicz, “Don’t Send Your Kid to the Ivy League,” the second a response by J.D. Chapman, “Send Your Kid to the Ivy League!” So two things as front-matter to this.  First – at least as a college educator – both articles were interesting, to me.  And for that matter, as someone raising two kids and as a parent doing things for my … Continue reading

The Aurelius File (2) – Ukraine, Russia, Game Theory and Theory of Constraints – Putin Doesn’t want a War He Can’t Win

new ornament seaml bord smallerer

Note to reader: the following essay is important for understanding that constraints should lead us to doubt that Putin will seek or engage in a large scale invasion that risks direct confrontation with the west or that imperils eastern European countries that are members of NATO.  More importantly it puts into focus Putin’s understanding and Modus Operandi that he only engages in conflict when he can control the terms of the conflict.  Much as happened since April 13, 2014 when this was written – for an update current as of August 31st please see here. * * * * * … Continue reading

The Importance of The New Republic and of Criticizing its Latter-Day Editorial Quality

iStock_000012911771Small

First, what this is not about. I often have exchanges with other people posting comments at The New Republic.  This article is not about that, or them.  This article is about the scathing nature of a few of the posts I’ve put on articles published on the The New Republic.  The article is directed to the editorial staff of that journal by whom I could not be made happier than if they made changes and improvements to their own work, so that I did not feel compelled to write the scathing remarks that I several times lately have. A Lamentable … Continue reading

Bluedog Must Reads

iStock_000006964159Small

If you are coming to this site for the first time it is most likely because you were drawn here (possibly in great anger) by comments I’ve made elsewhere on the web.  My most common places to comment are The New Republic (Livefyre), The National Review (Disqus) and the “manosphere” website of what may fairly be described as the Christian traditionalist, Dalrock (Dalrock – if you object to the attribution, let me know).  I used to comment fairly often on A Voice for Men but while I continue to struggle with my long promised and long overdue piece on Paul … Continue reading

Canyons and Peaks of Poverty in Black and White – US Census Table 696 in Pictures – A Genie Whose Release Only Its Master Can Contain (5)

iStock_000008648591Small

The subject could barely seem more timely with Ta-Nehisi Coates’s broadly heard call in The Atlantic for a new reckoning on reparations, or if not a new reckoning, then re-opening of “the discussion”. Just days in print and echoes of Coates are heard everywhere: Isaac Chotiner in The New Republic – “Coates’s argument shouldn’t be too controversial.” Isaac Chotiner in The New Republic days later – shows us how smart he is at issuing glib and dismissive rebuttals when he’s thought days ahead on a generalist argument and the respondents have thought for seconds on the specific application which he … Continue reading

The Nautilus Intermission and the Troubling Person of Paul Elam – A Genie Whose Release Only its Master Can Contain

The nautilus shell - the geometrician's map to the Vortex.  A living example of Jacob Bernoulli's Spira Mirabilis, simultaneously putting into frame the natural logarithm e, the Golden Ratio and the Fibonacci Sequence.

We have followed a structure leading up to our argument about Paul Elam, the structure completes the first circle of a vortex – the inner circle – the circle that puts into focus the “men’s rights movement” and more broadly how the MRM in axis with the manosphere and MGTOW or “Men Going Their Own Way” provide a picture for us that allows us to see the pattern at play when the dangerous Genie of Identity Politics is unleashed. MRM is the first swirl of the vortex as the Genie leaves the bottle.  The first swirl is useful, because being … Continue reading

One Feminism to Rule them All – A Genie Whose Release Only its Master Can Contain (4) Betty Friedan’s Unlikely Torch Bearer Part IV

iStock_000008648591Small

Feminism’s Trade Name Wars The word “feminism” is a brand.  As a brand it holds value – profound value, qualitative and quantitative alike.  Profound and qualitative in that it is an compelling idea in a marketplace of ideas and it is a unifying siren (no pun intended) that draws bodies into a cause.  Profound and quantitative, it is a word that transacts in hard currency for those who are able to deploy it.  But unlike a corporate Trademarked brand, no one or no company or institution gets to claim feminism as its own and then sue for damages when someone … Continue reading

So You Think You’re Not a Progressive? … About that – A Genie Whose Release Only its Master Can Contain (4) Betty Friedan’s Unlikely Torch Bearer Part III

iStock_000008648591Small

Ok ok ok … So – I am cheating – I am skipping to (5) before I’ve even finished (4) and that is especially unfair of me since I have not yet delivered on the promised defense (I really wish there was a different word I could employ – but “defense” works for now but I think “qualified but enthusiastic endorsement” is a better descriptor) of Paul Elam which I’ve both promised and I really owe the ol’ chap now since I kind of let him have it in the second segment of 4. Bluedog will deliver, that bun is … Continue reading

A Genie Whose Release Only its Master Can Contain – Notice of Commission

iStock_000008648591Small

This is just a note to readers waiting in suspense for the next installment of A Genie Whose Release Only its Master Can Contain – where, having articulated where I agree with reasonable criticisms of Paul Elam’s leadership in the MRM, I’m now moving on to lay out a  case that these criticisms can be taken too far – much to the detriment of the critics themselves, and to draw up a defense of Elam and urging the mainstream media, but the political left especially, to take a deeper look at the man and the person, … I understand I am … Continue reading

“This One for Belial” – A Genie Whose Release Only Its Master Can Contain (4) – Betty Friedan’s Unlikely Torch Bearer Part II

iStock_000008648591Small

(Continued from earlier - Betty Friedan’s Unlikely Torch Bearer, Part I - scroll to below article for outline to the series) “What determines people’s fate is not the behaviour of powerful rulers but how children learn.” Simon Goldhill The Temple in Jerusalem ______________________________ IV. “This One for Belial” – Betty Friedan’s Unlikely Torch Bearer Part II   (Please read the Front Matter to this section before proceeding, then also have a look at this cartoon: http://bcs.worthpublishers.com/OSC/eBookPlayerFiles/Myers/images/480/Myers8e_3_17UN10.jpg … and now we can get on with it) I’ve been following the MRM and the manosphere long enough to have observed Paul Elam get covered in … Continue reading

A Genie Whose Release only its Master can Contain (4) – Betty Friedan’s Unlikely Torch Bearer, Part I

iStock_000008648591Small

(Continued from - A Genie Whose Release only its Master can Contain - Reverse Potemkin Villages, Concealed Dashboard Dials and the Danger of Taking Cues from David Futrelle - scroll to below article for outline to the series)    …a “dangerous idea” is one which makes conventional  opinion, which I expect most of you hold, squawk with indignation and dislike of the person who advances it.  If it doesn’t do those things, it isn’t dangerous in the first place. Christopher Hitchens IV.  Betty Friedan’s Unlikely Torch Bearer    From David Futrelle’s oblique negative coverage, to the mothership A Voice for Men, to “christomanosphere” sites … Continue reading

A Genie Whose Release only its Master can Contain (3) – Reverse Potemkin Villages, Concealed Dashboard Dials and the Danger of Taking Cues from David Futrelle

iStock_000008648591Small

(Continued from yesterday - A Genie Whose Release only its Master can Contain Part I - Critique – As Important to Survival as Breakfast - See below article for series outline)   III.  Reverse Potemkin Villages, Concealed Dashboard Dials and the Danger of Taking Cues from David Futrelle In one of his interminably awful articles* Futrelle expresses some guarding against allowing his blog to slip into “All A Voice for Men, All the Time” … where I guess AVfM had given him a lot of content to lampoon in the lead up. I’ve had a similar concern with my own small blog only my worry … Continue reading

A Genie Whose Release only its Master can Contain (2) Critique – As Important to Survival as Breakfast

iStock_000008648591Small

(Continued from yesterday – A Genie Whose Release only its Master can Contain Part I - How the Left Created the Men’s Rights Movement and Will Decide its Future - see below article for outline to the series) II.  Critique - As Important to Survival as Breakfast I have long been of the school that we learn from our failures – often learning best from failure.  Indeed – the power of failure to teach makes it incumbent upon the person with a desire to perform competently and professional to specifically arrange for his or her failures in advance, so that by the time … Continue reading

A Genie Whose Release only its Master can Contain (1) How the Left Created the Men’s Rights Movement and will Decide its Future

iStock_000008648591Small

 Section I – Introduction to the Series A Genie Whose Release only its Master Can Contain When the right does identity politics it’s racism, tantamount to fascism.  And it’s scary. When the left does identity politics it’s goodness and inclusion.  It’s progressive! That is the central problem of identity politics – the contradiction at its core.  It is the poison pill that always existed in identity politics whatever benefit or benefits such politics were ever perceived to render.  It’s the poison pill that any honest person must have always known was there.  And it’s the poison pill that would inevitably … Continue reading

Chris Christi and “the need for smaller government”

iStock_000015719705XSmall

New Jersey governor Chris Christi’s been getting a lot of news lately.  We expect that his repetition of a standard Republican canard wouldn’t normally be worth the CNN morning news broadcast but not today.  Chris Christi has reminded us about the “need for smaller government”. Bluedog is shocked. A centrist looks on this statement “a need for smaller government”, and, oddly enough, “nods”.  Yet there’s a different sentiment to how the centrist looks at that statement than how an extremist or a run-of-the-mill true believer will nod. There is something about either the universe or, more likely, our constitutionally finite … Continue reading

“Squeezed from the right and the left” – Against Nullification

Death of the Sons of Jerubbaal by Gustave Dore

“A Blue Dog was a yellow dog Democrat squeezed from the right and the left and so he turned blue.” Representative Heath Shuler (D-NC) A Bluedog’s Credo ____________________________   I went to a Buddhist sangha and was not surprised that I found people.  I went to India and worked with my Hindu colleagues and was not surprised that they are people.  I keep good company with a hefty number of unbelievers and I find that all of them, are moral people.  I have often been to church, pretty much was raised with church, and am not surprised that people are … Continue reading

The Better and Worse Halves of the Trouble with Identity Politics

Final scene from Goethe's "Faust"

I engaged in a comments-based discussion over at the New Republic the other day and my interlocuter acknowledged some of what I had to say, while politely disagreeing with other – all good enough.  While we covered a lot of ground there’s one point she made that matters, strategically, more than anything else we discussed.  She stated that despite reasonable concerns or objections about identity politics, that identity politics still has value because it serves to draw people into politics – or at least into the public sphere, who wouldn’t otherwise come, and it serves to create the basis by … Continue reading

Dr Rollo Diagnoses Men being Possessive of Women – I Suggest an Antidote: Clouds

Beautiful sunset

Those still in the dark, who are still taking their cues on the manosphere from its Haman will fault me for it, but I have long followed Rollo Tomassi and his blog, TheRationalMale, and not only do I follow it, I admire Mr. Tomassi, I consider his writing and analysis penetrating and I reckon his writing to be humanist - even though he seems to claim to try not to make it so.  Rollo’s most recent piece on “Possession” is concerned specifically with both how bad an idea it is for men to be possessive of women and why it is … Continue reading

New Series – Reason 2 of ∞ that the Left Should Pay ZERO Attention to David Futrelle

Integrity

Let us consider the equation: Though it should be familiar enough to kindle uncomfortable memories of adolescence and all the varieties of ways adolescence teased, mocked and baffled us, leave it to the manosphere, and its self-appointed Chief Executive Critic to breath new life into the abstract world of math! … as x approaches infinity … 1/x gets infinitesimally closer to zero … and so we see that as the reasons David Futrelle is full of crap pile higher and higher into the majesty of the heavens, the reasons that it may have seemed like you should have listened to him … Continue reading

Bluedog Writes a Letter to the Left and Right, cc – Manosphere

Pen and Quill

Actually I wrote this into a sort of postscript that I added to yesterday’s post (which has some additional substance matter), but the letter kind of stands on its own so I’m giving it its own place. * * * * * * * * * *   Dear Right and Dear Left, It is with the utmost regret and dismay that I write to inform you that you have both disenfranchised half the American population, at the same time as your politics and ideologies have failed the same massive group. Just a few simple hints: Right: you are always really jazzed up on … Continue reading

The Aurelius File (1) – Obama Controlling the Frame – Of Creeping Fascism and the Arguments Obama will not Make or Address in his Tuesday Speech on Syria

Not as much “crystal ball” as it is telepathy or mind reading. You see it takes a Democrat to know a Democrat.  And the trouble here is: President Obama isn’t acting like a Democrat If you fall into any of the “oppose Obama” categories, this is a fact that may be lost on you.  But if you are not generally in one of those categories and you happen to be possessed of a curious nature then this is a matter of wonder.  It’s the kind of thing that gets you thinking: What is he thinking? And  if you happen to … Continue reading